我说的是一款没有得分上限的动作游戏,也没有办法通过重玩动作等方式来验证服务器上的分数。

我真正需要的是在Flash/PHP中最强的加密,以及一种防止人们调用PHP页面而不是通过我的Flash文件的方法。我在过去尝试了一些简单的方法,对一个分数进行多次调用,完成一个校验和/斐波那契序列等,也用Amayeta SWF加密混淆SWF,但他们最终都被黑客入侵了。

感谢StackOverflow的响应,我现在从Adobe找到了更多的信息- http://www.adobe.com/devnet/flashplayer/articles/secure_swf_apps_12.html和https://github.com/mikechambers/as3corelib -我认为我可以使用加密。但我不确定这是否能让我绕过CheatEngine。

我需要知道AS2和AS3的最佳解决方案,如果它们是不同的。

主要的问题似乎是TamperData和LiveHTTP报头,但我知道还有更高级的黑客工具,比如CheatEngine(感谢Mark Webster)


当前回答

没有办法使它完全不可攻击,因为它很容易反编译swf,一个熟练的开发黑客可以跟踪您的代码,并找出如何绕过您可能使用的任何加密系统。

如果你只是想通过使用TamperData这样的简单工具来阻止孩子作弊,那么你可以生成一个加密密钥,在启动时传递给SWF。然后,在将高分传递回PHP代码之前,使用http://code.google.com/p/as3crypto/之类的东西对高分进行加密。然后在服务器端解密,然后将其存储到数据库中。

其他回答

The way that a new popular arcade mod does it is that it sends data from the flash to php, back to flash (or reloads it), then back to php. This allows you to do anything you want to compare the data as well bypass post data/decryption hacks and the like. One way that it does this is by assigning 2 randomized values from php into the flash (which you cannot grab or see even if running a realtime flash data grabber), using a mathematical formula to add the score with the random values then checking it using the same formula to reverse it to see if the score matches it when it finally goes to the php at the end. These random values are never visible as well as it also times the transaction taking place and if it's any more than a couple seconds then it also flags it as cheating because it assumes you have stopped the send to try to figure out the randomized values or run the numbers through some type of cipher to return possible random values to compare with the score value.

如果你问我,这似乎是一个很好的解决方案,有人认为使用这种方法有什么问题吗?或者可能的解决方法?

I made kind of workaround... I had a gave where scores incremented ( you always get +1 score ). First, I started to count from random num (let's say 14 ) and when I display the scores, just showed the scores var minus 14. This was so if the crackers are looking for example for 20, they won't find it ( it will be 34 in the memory ). Second, since I know what the next point should be... I used adobe crypto library, to create the hash of what the next point should be. When I have to increment the scores, I check if the hash of the incremented scores is equal to the hash is should be. If the cracker have changed the points in the memory, the hashes are not equal. I perform some server-side verification and when I got different points from game and from the PHP, I know that cheating were involved. Here is snippet ot my code ( I'm using Adobe Crypto libraty MD5 class and random cryptography salt. callPhp() is my server side validation )

private function addPoint(event:Event = null):void{
            trace("expectedHash: " + expectedHash + "  || new hash: " + MD5.hash( Number(SCORES + POINT).toString() + expectedHashSalt) );
            if(expectedHash == MD5.hash( Number(SCORES + POINT).toString() + expectedHashSalt)){
                SCORES +=POINT;
                callPhp();
                expectedHash = MD5.hash( Number(SCORES + POINT).toString() + expectedHashSalt);
            } else {
                //trace("cheat engine usage");
            }
        }

使用这种技术+ SWF混淆,我能够阻止饼干。此外,当我将分数发送到服务器端时,我使用自己的小型加密/解密功能。类似这样的代码(服务器端代码不包括在内,但你可以看到算法并用PHP编写):

package  {

    import bassta.utils.Hash;

    public class ScoresEncoder {

        private static var ranChars:Array;
        private static var charsTable:Hash;

        public function ScoresEncoder() {

        }

        public static function init():void{

            ranChars = String("qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm").split("")

            charsTable = new Hash({
                "0": "x",
                "1": "f",
                "2": "q",
                "3": "z",
                "4": "a",
                "5": "o",
                "6": "n",
                "7": "p",
                "8": "w",
                "9": "y"

            });

        }

        public static function encodeScore(_s:Number):String{

            var _fin:String = "";

            var scores:String = addLeadingZeros(_s);
            for(var i:uint = 0; i< scores.length; i++){
                //trace( scores.charAt(i) + " - > " + charsTable[ scores.charAt(i) ] );
                _fin += charsTable[ scores.charAt(i) ];
            }

            return _fin;

        }

        public static function decodeScore(_s:String):String{

            var _fin:String = "";

            var decoded:String = _s;

            for(var i:uint = 0; i< decoded.length; i++){
                //trace( decoded.charAt(i) + " - > "  + charsTable.getKey( decoded.charAt(i) ) );
                _fin += charsTable.getKey( decoded.charAt(i) );
            }

            return _fin;

        }

        public static function encodeScoreRand(_s:Number):String{
            var _fin:String = "";

            _fin += generateRandomChars(10) + encodeScore(_s) + generateRandomChars(3)

            return _fin;
        }

        public static function decodeScoreRand(_s:String):Number{

            var decodedString:String = _s;
            var decoded:Number;

            decodedString = decodedString.substring(10,13);         
            decodedString = decodeScore(decodedString);

            decoded = Number(decodedString);

            return decoded;
        }

        public static function generateRandomChars(_length:Number):String{

            var newRandChars:String = "";

            for(var i:uint = 0; i< _length; i++){
                newRandChars+= ranChars[ Math.ceil( Math.random()*ranChars.length-1 )];
            }

            return newRandChars;
        }

        private static function addLeadingZeros(_s:Number):String{

            var _fin:String;

            if(_s < 10 ){
                 _fin = "00" + _s.toString();
            }

            if(_s >= 10 && _s < 99 ) {
                 _fin = "0" + _s.toString();
            }

            if(_s >= 100 ) {
                _fin = _s.toString();
            }           

            return _fin;
        }


    }//end
}

然后我把这个变量和其他的假变量一起发送,它就会迷失在其中…对于小型flash游戏来说,这是一项艰巨的任务,但当涉及到奖品时,有些人就会变得贪婪。如果你需要任何帮助,给我写个便条。

欢呼,图标

Whenever your highscore system is based on the fact that the Flash application sends unencrpyted/unsigned highscore data via the network, that can be intercepted and manipulated/replayed. The answer follows from that: encrypt (decently!) or cryptographically sign highscore data. This, at least, makes it harder for people to crack your highscore system because they'll need to extract the secret key from your SWF file. Many people will probably give up right there. On the other hand, all it takes is a singly person to extract the key and post it somewhere.

真正的解决方案包括在Flash应用程序和高分数据库之间进行更多的通信,以便后者能够验证给定的分数是否真实。这可能很复杂,这取决于你的游戏类型。

想要得到你想要的是不可能的。Flash应用程序的内部总是部分可访问的,特别是当你知道如何使用像CheatEngine这样的东西时,这意味着无论你的网站和浏览器<->服务器通信有多安全,它仍然会相对简单地克服。

我通常会在高分条目中加入游戏回合的“幽灵数据”。所以如果我在制作一款赛车游戏,我就会包含回放数据。你通常已经拥有关于重玩功能或幽灵赛车功能的重玩数据(游戏邦注:与你的上一场比赛进行比赛,或与排行榜上排名14的玩家的幽灵进行比赛)。

检查这些是非常费力的工作,但如果目标是验证竞赛中的前10名参赛作品是否合法,这可能是对其他人已经指出的安全措施库的有用补充。

如果你的目标是将高分列表保持在网上,直到时间结束,而没有人需要查看它们,这不会给你带来太多好处。