在Java中,当有人问:
什么是多态性?
重载或重写是可以接受的答案吗?
我认为事情远不止如此。
如果你有一个抽象基类,它定义了一个没有实现的方法,并且你在子类中定义了这个方法,这仍然是覆盖的吗?
我认为超负荷肯定不是正确的答案。
在Java中,当有人问:
什么是多态性?
重载或重写是可以接受的答案吗?
我认为事情远不止如此。
如果你有一个抽象基类,它定义了一个没有实现的方法,并且你在子类中定义了这个方法,这仍然是覆盖的吗?
我认为超负荷肯定不是正确的答案。
当前回答
什么是多态性?
来自java教程
多态性的字典定义是指生物学中的一个原理,在这个原理中,一个有机体或物种可以有许多不同的形式或阶段。这个原则也可以应用于面向对象编程和Java语言等语言。类的子类可以定义它们自己独特的行为,同时还可以共享父类的一些相同功能。
通过对实例和定义的考虑,应采用覆盖式回答。
关于你的第二个问题:
如果你有一个抽象基类,它定义了一个没有实现的方法,并且你在子类中定义了这个方法,这仍然是覆盖的吗?
它应该被称为重写。
看一下这个例子,了解不同类型的覆盖。
基类不提供实现,子类必须重写完整方法-(抽象) 基类提供默认实现,子类可以改变行为 子类通过调用super.methodName()作为第一条语句向基类实现添加扩展 基类定义了算法的结构(Template方法),子类将覆盖算法的一部分
代码片段:
import java.util.HashMap;
abstract class Game implements Runnable{
protected boolean runGame = true;
protected Player player1 = null;
protected Player player2 = null;
protected Player currentPlayer = null;
public Game(){
player1 = new Player("Player 1");
player2 = new Player("Player 2");
currentPlayer = player1;
initializeGame();
}
/* Type 1: Let subclass define own implementation. Base class defines abstract method to force
sub-classes to define implementation
*/
protected abstract void initializeGame();
/* Type 2: Sub-class can change the behaviour. If not, base class behaviour is applicable */
protected void logTimeBetweenMoves(Player player){
System.out.println("Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime");
}
/* Type 3: Base class provides implementation. Sub-class can enhance base class implementation by calling
super.methodName() in first line of the child class method and specific implementation later */
protected void logGameStatistics(){
System.out.println("Base class: logGameStatistics:");
}
/* Type 4: Template method: Structure of base class can't be changed but sub-class can some part of behaviour */
protected void runGame() throws Exception{
System.out.println("Base class: Defining the flow for Game:");
while ( runGame) {
/*
1. Set current player
2. Get Player Move
*/
validatePlayerMove(currentPlayer);
logTimeBetweenMoves(currentPlayer);
Thread.sleep(500);
setNextPlayer();
}
logGameStatistics();
}
/* sub-part of the template method, which define child class behaviour */
protected abstract void validatePlayerMove(Player p);
protected void setRunGame(boolean status){
this.runGame = status;
}
public void setCurrentPlayer(Player p){
this.currentPlayer = p;
}
public void setNextPlayer(){
if ( currentPlayer == player1) {
currentPlayer = player2;
}else{
currentPlayer = player1;
}
}
public void run(){
try{
runGame();
}catch(Exception err){
err.printStackTrace();
}
}
}
class Player{
String name;
Player(String name){
this.name = name;
}
public String getName(){
return name;
}
}
/* Concrete Game implementation */
class Chess extends Game{
public Chess(){
super();
}
public void initializeGame(){
System.out.println("Child class: Initialized Chess game");
}
protected void validatePlayerMove(Player p){
System.out.println("Child class: Validate Chess move:"+p.getName());
}
protected void logGameStatistics(){
super.logGameStatistics();
System.out.println("Child class: Add Chess specific logGameStatistics:");
}
}
class TicTacToe extends Game{
public TicTacToe(){
super();
}
public void initializeGame(){
System.out.println("Child class: Initialized TicTacToe game");
}
protected void validatePlayerMove(Player p){
System.out.println("Child class: Validate TicTacToe move:"+p.getName());
}
}
public class Polymorphism{
public static void main(String args[]){
try{
Game game = new Chess();
Thread t1 = new Thread(game);
t1.start();
Thread.sleep(1000);
game.setRunGame(false);
Thread.sleep(1000);
game = new TicTacToe();
Thread t2 = new Thread(game);
t2.start();
Thread.sleep(1000);
game.setRunGame(false);
}catch(Exception err){
err.printStackTrace();
}
}
}
输出:
Child class: Initialized Chess game
Base class: Defining the flow for Game:
Child class: Validate Chess move:Player 1
Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime
Child class: Validate Chess move:Player 2
Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime
Base class: logGameStatistics:
Child class: Add Chess specific logGameStatistics:
Child class: Initialized TicTacToe game
Base class: Defining the flow for Game:
Child class: Validate TicTacToe move:Player 1
Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime
Child class: Validate TicTacToe move:Player 2
Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime
Base class: logGameStatistics:
其他回答
多态性是类实例的一种能力,它的行为就像它是其继承树中另一个类的实例一样,通常是它的祖先类之一。例如,在Java中,所有的类都继承自Object。因此,您可以创建Object类型的变量,并将任何类的实例分配给它。
An override is a type of function which occurs in a class which inherits from another class. An override function "replaces" a function inherited from the base class, but does so in such a way that it is called even when an instance of its class is pretending to be a different type through polymorphism. Referring to the previous example, you could define your own class and override the toString() function. Because this function is inherited from Object, it will still be available if you copy an instance of this class into an Object-type variable. Normally, if you call toString() on your class while it is pretending to be an Object, the version of toString which will actually fire is the one defined on Object itself. However, because the function is an override, the definition of toString() from your class is used even when the class instance's true type is hidden behind polymorphism.
重载是定义具有相同名称但具有不同参数的多个方法的操作。它与覆盖或多态性无关。
具体地说重载或重写并没有给出全貌。多态性就是对象根据其类型专门化其行为的能力。
我不同意这里的一些答案,因为重载是一种多态形式(参数多态),在这种情况下,具有相同名称的方法可以具有不同的行为,给出不同的参数类型。一个很好的例子是操作符重载。您可以定义“+”来接受不同类型的参数——例如字符串或int型——并且基于这些类型,“+”将具有不同的行为。
多态性还包括继承和重写方法,尽管它们在基类型中可以是抽象的或虚拟的。在基于继承的多态性方面,Java只支持单个类继承,将其多态行为限制为单个基类型链。Java支持多个接口的实现,这是另一种形式的多态行为。
我觉得你们的概念混在一起了。多态性是对象在运行时表现不同的能力。要实现这一点,您需要两个必要条件:
后期绑定 继承。
重载与覆盖的意思不同,这取决于你所使用的语言。例如,在Java中不存在重写,而是重载。子类中可以使用对其基类具有不同签名的重载方法。否则它们将被重写(请注意,我的意思是现在没有办法从对象外部调用基类方法)。
然而,在c++中却不是这样。任何重载方法,无论签名是否相同(不同的量,不同的类型),都可以被重写。也就是说,当从子类对象外部调用基类的方法时,基类的方法在子类中显然不再可用。
所以答案是在Java中使用重载。在任何其他语言中都可能不同,因为它发生在c++中
术语重载指的是具有相同名称的东西的多个版本,通常是具有不同参数列表的方法
public int DoSomething(int objectId) { ... }
public int DoSomething(string objectName) { ... }
这些函数可能做同样的事情但你可以选择用ID或名称来调用它。与继承、抽象类等无关。
覆盖通常指的是多态性,就像你在问题中描述的那样
什么是多态性?
来自java教程
多态性的字典定义是指生物学中的一个原理,在这个原理中,一个有机体或物种可以有许多不同的形式或阶段。这个原则也可以应用于面向对象编程和Java语言等语言。类的子类可以定义它们自己独特的行为,同时还可以共享父类的一些相同功能。
通过对实例和定义的考虑,应采用覆盖式回答。
关于你的第二个问题:
如果你有一个抽象基类,它定义了一个没有实现的方法,并且你在子类中定义了这个方法,这仍然是覆盖的吗?
它应该被称为重写。
看一下这个例子,了解不同类型的覆盖。
基类不提供实现,子类必须重写完整方法-(抽象) 基类提供默认实现,子类可以改变行为 子类通过调用super.methodName()作为第一条语句向基类实现添加扩展 基类定义了算法的结构(Template方法),子类将覆盖算法的一部分
代码片段:
import java.util.HashMap;
abstract class Game implements Runnable{
protected boolean runGame = true;
protected Player player1 = null;
protected Player player2 = null;
protected Player currentPlayer = null;
public Game(){
player1 = new Player("Player 1");
player2 = new Player("Player 2");
currentPlayer = player1;
initializeGame();
}
/* Type 1: Let subclass define own implementation. Base class defines abstract method to force
sub-classes to define implementation
*/
protected abstract void initializeGame();
/* Type 2: Sub-class can change the behaviour. If not, base class behaviour is applicable */
protected void logTimeBetweenMoves(Player player){
System.out.println("Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime");
}
/* Type 3: Base class provides implementation. Sub-class can enhance base class implementation by calling
super.methodName() in first line of the child class method and specific implementation later */
protected void logGameStatistics(){
System.out.println("Base class: logGameStatistics:");
}
/* Type 4: Template method: Structure of base class can't be changed but sub-class can some part of behaviour */
protected void runGame() throws Exception{
System.out.println("Base class: Defining the flow for Game:");
while ( runGame) {
/*
1. Set current player
2. Get Player Move
*/
validatePlayerMove(currentPlayer);
logTimeBetweenMoves(currentPlayer);
Thread.sleep(500);
setNextPlayer();
}
logGameStatistics();
}
/* sub-part of the template method, which define child class behaviour */
protected abstract void validatePlayerMove(Player p);
protected void setRunGame(boolean status){
this.runGame = status;
}
public void setCurrentPlayer(Player p){
this.currentPlayer = p;
}
public void setNextPlayer(){
if ( currentPlayer == player1) {
currentPlayer = player2;
}else{
currentPlayer = player1;
}
}
public void run(){
try{
runGame();
}catch(Exception err){
err.printStackTrace();
}
}
}
class Player{
String name;
Player(String name){
this.name = name;
}
public String getName(){
return name;
}
}
/* Concrete Game implementation */
class Chess extends Game{
public Chess(){
super();
}
public void initializeGame(){
System.out.println("Child class: Initialized Chess game");
}
protected void validatePlayerMove(Player p){
System.out.println("Child class: Validate Chess move:"+p.getName());
}
protected void logGameStatistics(){
super.logGameStatistics();
System.out.println("Child class: Add Chess specific logGameStatistics:");
}
}
class TicTacToe extends Game{
public TicTacToe(){
super();
}
public void initializeGame(){
System.out.println("Child class: Initialized TicTacToe game");
}
protected void validatePlayerMove(Player p){
System.out.println("Child class: Validate TicTacToe move:"+p.getName());
}
}
public class Polymorphism{
public static void main(String args[]){
try{
Game game = new Chess();
Thread t1 = new Thread(game);
t1.start();
Thread.sleep(1000);
game.setRunGame(false);
Thread.sleep(1000);
game = new TicTacToe();
Thread t2 = new Thread(game);
t2.start();
Thread.sleep(1000);
game.setRunGame(false);
}catch(Exception err){
err.printStackTrace();
}
}
}
输出:
Child class: Initialized Chess game
Base class: Defining the flow for Game:
Child class: Validate Chess move:Player 1
Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime
Child class: Validate Chess move:Player 2
Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime
Base class: logGameStatistics:
Child class: Add Chess specific logGameStatistics:
Child class: Initialized TicTacToe game
Base class: Defining the flow for Game:
Child class: Validate TicTacToe move:Player 1
Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime
Child class: Validate TicTacToe move:Player 2
Base class: Move Duration: player.PlayerActTime - player.MoveShownTime
Base class: logGameStatistics: