我需要知道什么时候在JVM中调用finalize()方法。我创建了一个测试类,当finalize()方法被重写时写入文件。它没有被执行。有人能告诉我为什么它不能执行吗?


当前回答

由于JVM调用finalize()方法存在不确定性(不确定被重写的finalize()是否会被执行),为了研究目的,观察finalize()调用时发生的情况的更好方法是通过命令System.gc()强制JVM调用垃圾收集。

具体来说,finalize()在对象不再使用时被调用。但是当我们试图通过创建新对象来调用它时,它的调用是不确定的。因此,为了确定起见,我们创建了一个空对象c,它显然没有未来的用途,因此我们看到对象c的finalize调用。

例子

class Car {

    int maxspeed;

    Car() {
        maxspeed = 70;
    }

    protected void finalize() {

    // Originally finalize method does nothing, but here we override finalize() saying it to print some stmt
    // Calling of finalize is uncertain. Difficult to observe so we force JVM to call it by System.gc(); GarbageCollection

        System.out.println("Called finalize method in class Car...");
    }
}

class Bike {

    int maxspeed;

    Bike() {
        maxspeed = 50;
    }

    protected void finalize() {
        System.out.println("Called finalize method in class Bike...");
    }
}

class Example {

    public static void main(String args[]) {
        Car c = new Car();
        c = null;    // if c weren`t null JVM wouldn't be certain it's cleared or not, null means has no future use or no longer in use hence clears it
        Bike b = new Bike();
        System.gc();    // should clear c, but not b
        for (b.maxspeed = 1; b.maxspeed <= 70; b.maxspeed++) {
            System.out.print("\t" + b.maxspeed);
            if (b.maxspeed > 50) {
                System.out.println("Over Speed. Pls slow down.");
            }
        }
    }
}

输出

    Called finalize method in class Car...
            1       2       3       4       5       6       7       8       9
    10      11      12      13      14      15      16      17      18      19
    20      21      22      23      24      25      26      27      28      29
    30      31      32      33      34      35      36      37      38      39
    40      41      42      43      44      45      46      47      48      49
    50      51Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            52Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            53Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            54Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            55Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            56Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            57Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            58Over Speed. Pls slow down. 
            59Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            60Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            61Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            62Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            63Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            64Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            65Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            66Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            67Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            68Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            69Over Speed. Pls slow down.
            70Over Speed. Pls slow down.

注意:即使打印到70,并且在此之后对象b在程序中没有被使用,也不确定b是否被JVM清除,因为“调用的finalize方法在类Bike…”没有打印。

其他回答

最终确定方法是不保证的。当对象符合GC条件时调用此方法。在许多情况下,对象可能不会被垃圾收集。

Sometimes when it is destroyed, an object must make an action. For example, if an object has a non-java resource such as a file handle or a font, you can verify that these resources are released before destroying an object. To manage such situations, java offers a mechanism called "finalizing". By finalizing it, you can define specific actions that occur when an object is about to be removed from the garbage collector. To add a finalizer to a class simply define the finalize() method. Java execution time calls this method whenever it is about to delete an object of that class. Within the finalize method() you specify actions to be performed before destroying an object. The garbage collector is periodically searched for objects that no longer refer to any running state or indirectly any other object with reference. Before an asset is released, the Java runtime calls the finalize() method on the object. The finalize() method has the following general form:

protected void finalize(){
    // This is where the finalization code is entered
}

使用protected关键字,finalize()类之外的代码可以阻止对finalize()的访问。 务必要理解finalize()是在垃圾收集之前调用的。例如,当对象离开作用域时,它不会被调用。这意味着您无法知道finalize()何时或是否将执行。因此,程序必须提供其他方法来释放系统资源或对象使用的其他资源。不应该依赖finalize()来实现程序的正常运行。

查看Effective Java,第2版第27页。 第7项:避免终结词

终结器是不可预测的,通常是危险的,而且通常是不必要的。永远不要在终结器中做任何时间紧迫的事情。从来没有 依赖终结器更新关键持久状态。

要终止一个资源,请使用try-finally:

// try-finally块保证终止方法的执行 Foo Foo =新的Foo(…); 尝试{ //用foo做必须做的事情 ... }最后{ foo.terminate ();//显式终止方法 }

正如在https://wiki.sei.cmu.edu/confluence/display/java/MET12-J.+Do+not+use+finalizers上指出的那样,

There is no fixed time at which finalizers must be executed because time of execution depends on the Java Virtual Machine (JVM). The only guarantee is that any finalizer method that executes will do so sometime after the associated object has become unreachable (detected during the first cycle of garbage collection) and sometime before the garbage collector reclaims the associated object's storage (during the garbage collector's second cycle). Execution of an object's finalizer may be delayed for an arbitrarily long time after the object becomes unreachable. Consequently, invoking time-critical functionality such as closing file handles in an object's finalize() method is problematic.

JDK 18的最新消息

根据openjdk 18发布的JEPS 421, finalize()方法的终结和功能将被标记为已弃用(forRemoval=true),这意味着永久删除将在jdk 18之后的某个后续版本中进行。

从jdk 18开始,一个新的命令行选项——finalization=disabled禁用了所有地方的终结机制,甚至是jdk内部的声明。

这也与这里的这个问题有关,因为它被计划删除的原因是它包含的一些主要缺陷。其中一个缺陷是,从一个对象变得不可访问到调用它的终结器之间可能会经过很长一段时间。GC也不能保证任何终结器将被调用,这也是事实。