要创建一个带有公共方法的JavaScript类,我可以这样做:

function Restaurant() {}

Restaurant.prototype.buy_food = function(){
   // something here
}

Restaurant.prototype.use_restroom = function(){
   // something here
}

这样,我类的用户就可以:

var restaurant = new Restaurant();
restaurant.buy_food();
restaurant.use_restroom();

如何创建一个私有方法,可以由buy_food和use_restroom方法调用,但不能由类的用户外部调用?

换句话说,我希望我的方法实现能够做到:

Restaurant.prototype.use_restroom = function() {
   this.private_stuff();
}

但这是行不通的:

var r = new Restaurant();
r.private_stuff();

如何将private_stuff定义为私有方法,使两者都成立?

我读过Doug Crockford的文章几次,但它似乎不像“私有”方法可以被公共方法调用,而“特权”方法可以被外部调用。


当前回答

Class({  
    Namespace:ABC,  
    Name:"ClassL2",  
    Bases:[ABC.ClassTop],  
    Private:{  
        m_var:2  
    },  
    Protected:{  
        proval:2,  
        fight:Property(function(){  
            this.m_var--;  
            console.log("ClassL2::fight (m_var)" +this.m_var);  
        },[Property.Type.Virtual])  
    },  
    Public:{  
        Fight:function(){  
            console.log("ClassL2::Fight (m_var)"+this.m_var);  
            this.fight();  
        }  
    }  
});  

https://github.com/nooning/JSClass

其他回答

使用自调用函数和调用

JavaScript使用原型,不像面向对象语言那样有类(或方法)。JavaScript开发者需要用JavaScript思考。

维基百科:

与许多面向对象的语言不同,它们之间没有区别 函数定义和方法定义。而是区别 在函数调用期间发生;当函数作为方法调用时 对于一个对象,函数的本地this关键字绑定到该对象 对象用于该调用。

使用自调用函数和调用函数调用私有“方法”的解决方案:

var MyObject = (function () {
    
  // Constructor
  function MyObject(foo) {
    this._foo = foo;
  }

  function privateFun(prefix) {
    return prefix + this._foo;
  }
    
  MyObject.prototype.publicFun = function () {
    return privateFun.call(this, ">>");
  }
    
  return MyObject;

}());
var myObject = new MyObject("bar");
myObject.publicFun();      // Returns ">>bar"
myObject.privateFun(">>"); // ReferenceError: private is not defined

调用函数允许我们使用适当的上下文(this)调用私有函数。

使用Node.js更简单

如果你正在使用Node.js,你不需要IIFE,因为你可以利用模块加载系统:

function MyObject(foo) {
  this._foo = foo;
}
    
function privateFun(prefix) {
  return prefix + this._foo;
}

MyObject.prototype.publicFun = function () {
  return privateFun.call(this, ">>");
}
    
module.exports= MyObject;

加载文件:

var MyObject = require("./MyObject");
    
var myObject = new MyObject("bar");
myObject.publicFun();      // Returns ">>bar"
myObject.privateFun(">>"); // ReferenceError: private is not defined

(新!)未来JavaScript版本中的原生私有方法

TC39私有方法和JavaScript类的getter/setter建议是第3阶段。这意味着JavaScript很快就会在本地实现私有方法!

注意,JavaScript私有类字段在现代JavaScript版本中已经存在。

下面是一个如何使用它的例子:

class MyObject {

  // Private field
  #foo;
    
  constructor(foo) {
    this.#foo = foo;
  }

  #privateFun(prefix) {
   return prefix + this.#foo;
  }
    
  publicFun() {
    return this.#privateFun(">>");
  }

}

在旧的JavaScript引擎上运行这些代码可能需要JavaScript编译器/编译器。

PS:如果你想知道为什么是#前缀,请阅读这篇文章。

(已弃用)ES7绑定操作符

警告:绑定操作符TC39命题接近死亡https://github.com/tc39/proposal-bind-operator/issues/53#issuecomment-374271822

绑定操作符::是一个ECMAScript提议,在Babel(阶段0)中实现。

export default class MyObject {
  constructor (foo) {
    this._foo = foo;
  }

  publicFun () {
    return this::privateFun(">>");
  }
}

function privateFun (prefix) {
  return prefix + this._foo;
}

别啰嗦了。这是Javascript。使用命名约定。

在es6类工作了多年之后,我最近开始了一个es5项目(使用requireJS,它看起来已经非常冗长了)。我已经反复研究了这里提到的所有策略,基本上都可以归结为使用命名约定:

Javascript doesn't have scope keywords like private. Other developers entering Javascript will know this upfront. Therefore, a simple naming convention is more than sufficient. A simple naming convention of prefixing with an underscore solves the problem of both private properties and private methods. Let's take advantage of the Prototype for speed reasons, but lets not get anymore verbose than that. Let's try to keep the es5 "class" looking as closely to what we might expect in other backend languages (and treat every file as a class, even if we don't need to return an instance). Let's demonstrate with a more realistic module situation (we'll use old es5 and old requireJs).

my-tooltip.js

    define([
        'tooltip'
    ],
    function(
        tooltip
    ){

        function MyTooltip() {
            // Later, if needed, we can remove the underscore on some
            // of these (make public) and allow clients of our class
            // to set them.
            this._selector = "#my-tooltip"
            this._template = 'Hello from inside my tooltip!';
            this._initTooltip();
        }

        MyTooltip.prototype = {
            constructor: MyTooltip,

            _initTooltip: function () {
                new tooltip.tooltip(this._selector, {
                    content: this._template,
                    closeOnClick: true,
                    closeButton: true
                });
            }
        }

        return {
            init: function init() {
               new MyTooltip();  // <-- Our constructor adds our tooltip to the DOM so not much we need to do after instantiation.
            }

            // You could instead return a new instantiation, 
            // if later you do more with this class.
            /* 
            create: function create() {
               return new MyTooltip();
            }
            */
        }
    });

这是我得出的结论:

需要一类糖代码,你可以在这里找到。还支持保护,继承,虚拟,静态的东西…

;( function class_Restaurant( namespace )
{
    'use strict';

    if( namespace[ "Restaurant" ] ) return    // protect against double inclusions

        namespace.Restaurant = Restaurant
    var Static               = TidBits.OoJs.setupClass( namespace, "Restaurant" )


    // constructor
    //
    function Restaurant()
    {
        this.toilets = 3

        this.Private( private_stuff )

        return this.Public( buy_food, use_restroom )
    }

    function private_stuff(){ console.log( "There are", this.toilets, "toilets available") }

    function buy_food     (){ return "food"        }
    function use_restroom (){ this.private_stuff() }

})( window )


var chinese = new Restaurant

console.log( chinese.buy_food()      );  // output: food
console.log( chinese.use_restroom()  );  // output: There are 3 toilets available
console.log( chinese.toilets         );  // output: undefined
console.log( chinese.private_stuff() );  // output: undefined

// and throws: TypeError: Object #<Restaurant> has no method 'private_stuff'

老问题,但这是一个相当简单的任务,可以用核心JS正确解决…没有ES6的Class抽象。事实上,据我所知,类抽象甚至不能解决这个问题。

我们既可以使用老的构造函数,也可以使用Object.create()更好地完成这项工作。让我们先从构造函数开始。这本质上是一个与georgebrock的答案相似的解决方案,georgebrock的答案受到了批评,因为所有由Restaurant构造函数创建的餐厅都将具有相同的私有方法。我会努力克服这个限制。

function restaurantFactory(name,menu){ function Restaurant(name){ this.name = name; } function prototypeFactory(menu){ // This is a private function function calculateBill(item){ return menu[item] || 0; } // This is the prototype to be return { constructor: Restaurant , askBill : function(...items){ var cost = items.reduce((total,item) => total + calculateBill(item) ,0) return "Thank you for dining at " + this.name + ". Total is: " + cost + "\n" } , callWaiter : function(){ return "I have just called the waiter at " + this.name + "\n"; } } } Restaurant.prototype = prototypeFactory(menu); return new Restaurant(name,menu); } var menu = { water: 1 , coke : 2 , beer : 3 , beef : 15 , rice : 2 }, name = "Silver Scooop", rest = restaurantFactory(name,menu); console.log(rest.callWaiter()); console.log(rest.askBill("beer", "beef"));

现在显然我们不能从外部访问菜单,但我们可以很容易地重命名餐厅的name属性。

这也可以用object .create()来完成,在这种情况下,我们跳过构造函数,简单地像var rest = object .create(prototypeFactory(menu))那样做,然后像rest.name = name那样将name属性添加到rest对象。

以下是迄今为止我最喜欢的关于javascript中的私有/公共方法/成员和实例化:

这是文章:http://www.sefol.com/?p=1090

下面是一个例子:

var Person = (function () {

    //Immediately returns an anonymous function which builds our modules 
    return function (name, location) {

        alert("createPerson called with " + name);

        var localPrivateVar = name;

        var localPublicVar = "A public variable";

        var localPublicFunction = function () {
            alert("PUBLIC Func called, private var is :" + localPrivateVar)
        };

        var localPrivateFunction = function () {
            alert("PRIVATE Func called ")
        };

        var setName = function (name) {

            localPrivateVar = name;

        }

        return {

            publicVar: localPublicVar,

            location: location,

            publicFunction: localPublicFunction,

            setName: setName

        }

    }
})();


//Request a Person instance - should print "createPerson called with ben"
var x = Person("ben", "germany");

//Request a Person instance - should print "createPerson called with candide"
var y = Person("candide", "belgium");

//Prints "ben"
x.publicFunction();

//Prints "candide"
y.publicFunction();

//Now call a public function which sets the value of a private variable in the x instance
x.setName("Ben 2");

//Shouldn't have changed this : prints "candide"
y.publicFunction();

//Should have changed this : prints "Ben 2"
x.publicFunction();

JSFiddle: http://jsfiddle.net/northkildonan/kopj3dt3/1/